From Sacred Heart of Jesus, Conewago Mission Circuit
William Wappeler, S.J. 1741 – 1748
Theodore Schneider, S.J. 1748 – 1752
Matthias Manners Sittensberger , S.J. 1752 – 1758
Luke Geisler, S.J. 1758 – 1788
James Frambach, S.J. 1768 – 1800
Demetrius Gallitzen 1795 – 1799
John Baptist Causse, C.R. 1790 – 1795
Francis X. Brosius 1800 – 1804
Adolphus Lewis Debarth 1804 – 1812
Adam Britt, S.J. 1812 – 1818
Adam Marshall, S.J. 1818
Resident Priests in Saint Patrick Rectory
Leontius Huber, S.J. 1819 – 1820
D. Letgien, S.J. 1819
George D. Hogan 1820 – 1824
Patrick J. Dwen 1824 – 1838
Patrick Rafferty 1838 – 1840
Michael Steinbacker 1841
Gabriel Rumpler 1841 – 1842
Philip A. Sacchi 1841 – 1843
Daniel Kelly 1842
Roger J. Dietz 1843 – 1844
J.P. MacKin 1844
Basil Shorb 1844 – 1846
Michael F. Martin 1846 – 1854
Peter Cronenberg 1848
Patrick O’Reilly 1854
William McLaughlin 1854 – 1855
Silvester Eagle 1855 – 1866
Arthur McGinnis 1866
Edward Murray 1866 – 1870
Thomas F. McGovern* 1870 – 1873
*afterwards the second Bishop of Harrisburg*
John McElvain 1873
C.M. McMonigle 1873 – 1875
James Russell 1875
Charles Kenny 1875 – 1880
N. McMenamin 1879
L. McKenna 1880 – 1882
John W. Shanahan* 1882 – 1885
*afterwards third Bishop of Harrisburg*
T.P. Rafferty 1885
H.A. Loague 1885
James O’Reilly 1885 – 1890
Joseph E. Smith 1890
Charles J. Galligan 1890 – 1896
J.J. Kennedy 1892
F. McCarthy 1894
John C. Thompson 1896 – 1897
W.J. Hooman 1897 – 1904
T.F.X Doughtery 1901
William F. Brady 1902
P.J. Costigan 1902
James F. Clark 1903
Edward A. Burhard 1903
John J. Hollern 1904 – 1912
Daniel J. Carey 1904
H.A. Loague 1905
William J. O’Callaghan 1908
Mark E. Stock 1909
John L. Shields 1910
George Rice 1910 – 1912
Harry B. Strickland 1910
Arthur W. Brandt 1910
J.J. Finnegan 1911
J.J. Smythe 1911
Thomas L. McEntee 1912
William W. Whalen 1912
James McGrath 1912 – 1925
Matthew Scanlon 1912 – 1917
F.J. McManus 1912 – 1915
Patrick F. McGee 1915
Patrick J. Phelan 1916
Timothy O’Hanrahan 1918
Richard H. McLoughlin 1918 – 1922
Louis J. Yeager 1922 – 1929
Angelo Jannuzzi 1923 – 1930
George W. Brown 1925 – 1934
William Boyle 1926
John C. Zebrowski 1929
Edward A. Burhard 1929 – 1933
W.J.B. Weaver 1931 – 1933
Francis B. Kaminski 1932 – 1937
Michael M. Menko 1933 – 1934
John L. Shields 1934 – 1940
Carl B. Brady 1934 – 1944
Joseph N. Smarsh 1937 – 1938
Anthony F. Kane 1938
Michael M. Menko 1933 – 1934
Michael J. O’Flynn 1940 – 1947
Francis J. McCullough 1943 – 1944
Henry J. Moeller 1944
1944 – 1946
Joseph J. Bradley 1945 – 1950
Francis L. Mignot 1946 – 1949
Thomas J. McGough 1947 – 1966
John R. Campion 1948
Raymond E. Dougherty 1948 – 1953
Francis Vanhee, C.I.C.M. 1950
Lino Ciarlantini 1950 – 1952
1952 – 1954
Francis P. Filippelli 1954 – 1956
Francis Radisic, O.F.M 1954 – 1955
Vincent J. Smith 1955 – 1957
Charles R. Slough 1956 – 1958
Michael F. Barrett 1957 – 1959
James H. Fornwald 1958 – 1959
Paul M. Miller 1959 – 1961
Andre J. Meluskey 1959 – 1962
Wallace E. Sawdy 1961 – 1963
1962 – 1963
Ronald P. Ingalls 1963 – 1964
1963 – 1966
1964 – 1965
Leroy F. Spisak 1965 – 1967
John A. Batz 1966
Richard Zimmerman 1966 – 1969
Thomas J. Simpson 1966 – 1967
Raymond J. Orloski 1967 – 1969
1967 – 1981
Walter A. Halaburda 1969 – 1970
Thomas R. Brenner 1969 – 1972
Thomas M. McLernon 1970 – 1971
Juan Sonet 1970 – 1972
Ronald J. Moratelli 1970 – 1974
Clair A. Redding 1972 – 1975
J. Michael McFadden 1974 – 1976
Carl T. Tancredi 1975 – 1978
Edward A. Blackwell, Jr. 1976 – 1978
John J. Blandin, S.J. 1978 – 1991
Joseph D. Blascovich 1978 – 1987
Thomas R. Brenner 1981 – 1995
Kevin C. Rhoades* 1983 – 1985
*afterwards the ninth Bishop of Harrisburg, current Bishop of the Diocese of Fort Wayne/SouthBend*
Francis J. Karwacki 1985 – 1986
Thomas J. Rozman 1986 – 1989
William M Cawley 1988 – 1991
Michael M. Laicha 1989 – 1991
Joseph T. Scanlin 1991 – 1994
William M. Cawley 1993 – 2012
Tri Minh Luong 1994 – 1997
C. Anthony Miller 1995 – 2007
John Bosco Ikemeh, O.P. 1997 – 1999
Ukachukwu S. Onyeabor 2006 – 2007
Samuel E. Houser 2007 – 2013
Keith M. Carroll 2013 – 2014 (appointed adminstrator November 30th 2013 - May 2014 when appointed Pastor)
Keith M. Carroll 2014 – Oct, 2020
Hoa Van Nyguyen 2015 -
John B. Bateman Oct, 2020 -
Hoa Van Nyguyen 2015 -